By Michael Hathaway, CFP®, CFA®, AIF®
Conventional wisdom has it that “You cannot change what you do not measure.” The quote says “measure,” but I will take a small liberty and call it monitor, or monitoring—measuring the same piece(s) of data repeatedly over time. I am a financial planner who focuses on helping people improve their personal finances and align the use of their finite human capital with their purpose and values. In this article, I will describe and discuss personal financial monitoring (PFM) – keeping track over time of what matters in your personal finances – to help people achieve their financial goals.
Where Am I Today?
Before we can get started “monitoring” personal financial data, we need to determine where we are currently. Today. Right now. We’ll start with what is traditionally called a “balance sheet” (at least in the business world) and which is also sometimes called a “personal financial statement.” Either way, we’re going to add up all our “assets” (the things we own that have value) and add up all our “liabilities” (or debts, the things we’ve borrowed and must be repaid). I will give some examples of each in the sections below.
Finally, the difference between assets and liabilities will be our net worth.
Formula: Net Worth = Total Assets — Total Liabilities
Assets are usually listed first on a balance sheet (or on the left side) and are typically listed at current (or market) values, and in decreasing order of “liquidity.” Liquidity refers to the ability to transform an asset into cash (the most liquid asset), and that would require fewer costs associated with doing so. Therefore, actual cash and cash-like bank accounts (checking accounts) are usually listed at the top. Below them you would list bank savings accounts, money market accounts, certificates of deposit (CDs), after-tax investment accounts, restricted investment accounts (e.g., tax-deferred accounts like IRAs, 401(k)s, 403(b)s, etc.), Roth-style accounts (Roth IRAs, Roth 401(k)s), which can have some of their own restrictions, investment annuities, insurance with cash value, real property held for investment, private business investments, etc. These assets can simply be summed, or they can be put into subgroups and then summed; either way, we want to arrive at the total amount of assets.
Debts or liabilities are typically listed next on the balance sheet (or on the right side). The debts that are most likely to be repaid sooner (or that are paid off and reused continually, like credit cards) are listed first, followed by personal loans (usually unsecured) with a fixed payment schedule, then loans secured by a shorter-term asset (like a car loan or a piece of business equipment), or a longer-term asset (like a mortgage on a personal home or other investment property, or a business loan). These liabilities can also be simply summed (or grouped and summed) to arrive at a total amount of liabilities.
Now we use the formula above to arrive at a person’s net worth. This number represents a true measure of our financial position at this moment in time (only). This is a piece of personal financial information that we will want to monitor and assess over time. We want this value to increase; any action that increases an asset (like saving more) or decreases a liability (like paying down debt) will increase a person’s net worth. Below I will describe a new tool that greatly reduces the ongoing effort required to monitor assets, liabilities, and personal net worth.
How Does My Financial Position Change?
Now that we know where we are (today), we need a method to understand how our personal net worth is subject to change over time. Simplifying a little, the money we earn (our gross income) can be used in only one of four ways:
- Taxes: All of them: federal and state income taxes, FICA taxes, and some that are “like taxes” but simply expenses, like other paycheck deductions
- Debt payments: To reduce and/or eliminate liability accounts
- Savings: As cash, or transfer into other asset accounts
- Spending: To pay for living expenses like food, shelter, clothing, medical and dental care, recreation, entertainment, transportation, travel, vacations, charitable giving, etc.
Because our income can change from month to month (especially for those with variable paychecks), and because spending in total almost always changes monthly, many people give up trying to keep track of where their income goes. It’s just too much work. And sometimes we don’t like the truth about how we are spending our money.
Maybe these people will only save “by accident”; maybe they only make the minimum debt payments, and only when required; maybe they only think about taxes when it comes time to file tax returns every spring (based on the previous year’s income); and maybe they don’t really think about spending at all, other than “It really feels like we’re spending more lately for the same old things,” or “I can’t believe how much everything costs these days.” Fortunately, for the purposes of monitoring our personal finances (PFM), we can estimate our spending using the following method:
- Start with gross income. This might be an annual salary, your W-2, or the “total income” line of your federal tax return, or simply adding up paychecks over a period of time and then “annualizing” (that is, if you know how much you made over a three-month period, and the rest of the year looks similar to those three months, then you can simply multiply by four).
- Subtract all taxes. Use your paycheck “stub” as a guide to federal and state taxes withheld, FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare), state disability insurance, and unemployment premiums (if you have them), etc.
- For these purposes, I recommend excluding (from taxes) any paycheck withholding for pension or retirement savings accounts (e.g., 401(k)s), for medical and dental expenses, for any insurance or flex accounts, etc.).
- Some of these will show up as savings, others as spending.
- It is also important to look at your latest tax returns and add or subtract any amounts that you paid or received as a refund when you filed your tax return. I know this is inexact, but sometimes we must sacrifice precision for ease of use.
- For these purposes, I recommend excluding (from taxes) any paycheck withholding for pension or retirement savings accounts (e.g., 401(k)s), for medical and dental expenses, for any insurance or flex accounts, etc.).
- Subtract all debt payments made. This includes payments to all credit cards, auto loans, mortgages, etc.
- Subtract all savings transfers. This includes paycheck deductions for a pension and/or into a retirement savings account.
- Finally, the amount left over is the amount (approximately) that you spend during a year. If this seems too low (or too high), check to make sure everything is included and there is no “double counting.”
- Divide each of these amounts (taxes, debt payments, savings, and spending) by the total income amount that you started with to arrive at percentages (rates) for each category: tax rate, debt rate, savings rate, and spending rate. They should sum to 100%.
Congratulations! You now have your first set of data to begin monitoring your personal finances. Hopefully you will start to notice improvements in each area and increases in your personal net worth over time. Sometimes, as we begin to pay more attention to things, we start to make small adjustments without really thinking about it (if you’ve ever tried to “watch what you eat,” you know what I’m talking about).
As you see improvement, I believe you will be motivated even more to make the changes to further improve your personal financial situation. This improvement will allow you to have greater control over your spending and monthly cash flow, improve and reduce your use of consumer debt, increase your savings rate, and begin to enjoy the fruits of your labor. You are taking steps on the road to your financial freedom!
Consider the Elements App for Ongoing Monitoring
Earlier I mentioned there is a new tool I have begun using that can be used to reduce the effort required for regular updating of the financial data needed for PFM. The tool is called Elements, a mobile-first app that is easy to use, visually engaging, and connects to accounts online to enable continuous real-time updating. Many clients are able to connect to 100% of their accounts for updating, while a few have accounts that must be updated manually.
Elements provides ongoing monitoring of the user’s assets and liabilities, along with providing comparability through the use of “ratios,” such as Total Term (the number of years that all your assets, less liabilities, could fund your annual spending). Total Term is also broken out into its components: Liquid Term (years of annual spending provided by after-tax net assets), Qualified Term (years of annual spending provided by retirement account assets), Real Estate Term (years of annual spending provided for by real estate equity), and Business Term (years of annual spending provided by the equity available through privately held business interests). These ratios might be a little simplistic, in that they do not adjust for taxes that might be owed when liquidating the assets in exchange for cash in order to fund spending, but they provide useful analytical information nonetheless.
If you would like to learn more about Elements, please click the following link to visit their website: http://getelements.com.
Already interested in using the Elements app? Please use this link to a special “Elements page” on our website, where you can sign up to receive an email invitation to download the Elements app. Mike will follow-up to help you get started using the app for your own personal financial monitoring and making sense of the results.
Get in Touch for More Info
Do you have more questions about how to reach your financial goals? If you’d like to get in touch directly, please email me at Mike@wealthmatters.com or call (707) 428-5500.
About Mike
Michael Hathaway is a fiduciary financial advisor at Epsilon Financial Group, Inc., an independent, fee-only wealth management firm. Mike has worked in the finance industry for more than 20 years and brings a wealth of knowledge and experience in sophisticated financial planning to help his clients make sound financial decisions. He is known for caring deeply for his clients’ well-being, being compassionate, and thinking creatively to help clients attain their financial goals. He prioritizes building long-term relationships and takes the time to listen, understand, and explain so that his clients feel confident in their financial plan. Mike is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNERTM, Chartered Financial Analyst® (CFA®), and Accredited Investment Fiduciary® (AIF®) professional; he has a bachelor’s degree in cybernetics from UCLA and an MBA in finance and accounting from the University of Virginia. When he’s not working at Epsilon, you can find Mike enjoying anything related to exercise and fitness. He especially loves activities in the great outdoors, such as mountain biking, camping, hiking, and snowshoeing. In the fall of 2016, Mike successfully climbed to the top of Mount Whitney in a single day, the highest peak in the continental United States. To learn more about Mike, connect with him on LinkedIn.